BPD Update Online, Winter 2004
Editor's Prerogative
Editor's Prerogative
President's Report
Into Africa
Into Africa (cont)
Into Africa (cont)
I Am Not in Kansas Anymore
American-Israeli Online Exchange
The Update Interview
The Update Interview (cont)
The Update Interview (cont)
BPD Summer 2004 Policy Fellow Award
Organizational Report
Technology Corner
Technology Corner (cont)
Technology Corner (cont)
BackPage: Empty Chair
Photo Album: BPD Conference in Reno
Photo Album: BPD Conference in Reno (cont)
Photo Album: BPD Conference in Reno (cont)
BPD Membership Form
Contact BPD Update Online
Archives: 2003 - 2004
Archives: 2001 - 2002


by Ralph Holcomb

Waist Deep in the Big Muddy

If this issue of the Update has a theme, it could be "Hands Across the Sea." We hear from three reporters about ways to connect with others in Africa, the Mid-East, and Europe. And not a moment too soon, by my observation.

The other day I opened a social policy class discussion on Iraq which confirmed my worst fears, that our students are dangerously ignorant of the details of our involvement in the war after the war there. The most cogent and plaintive arguments about the issue came from my Hmong students who reminded us all of the terrible human cost of reneging on promises to vulnerable populations during times of war, a cost incurred by their parents after the Vietnam debacle. It is clear that having stepped in the mess of the war, we are now obligated to make good on our promises of peace and democracy in the most honorable way possible. As in Vietnam, the thoughtful humility required for the task is testing the capacities of our present administration to the maximum.

Students quizzed me about the parallels to the Viet Nam war, and I was reminded once again how old I'm getting. I hopped into my time machine and came down in 1965.

I was 14 years old and Walter Cronkite was the anchor for CBS evening news. Over my mom’s meatloaf dinners I'd stare at the blurred black and white images of terrified GI's ducking fire while dragging wounded comrades to safety through the jungle underbrush. Cronkite taught us a strange new geography over the dinner table: the Plain of Jars, Khe Sanh, Hue, the DMZ, the Ho Chi Minh Trail. There were also the hundred towns and hamlets and rivers now forgotten to all but those who left sons on that particular piece of real estate.

And then came the body count, the daily exercise in toting up the home and away team score. My parents, their patriotism forged during the Big One, asserted as they passed the mashed potatoes that this was the terrible price of freedom, and their assurance was enough for me. First we heard the home team score, the Americans killed or wounded that day. Then the South Vietnamese soldiers killed, and finally the away team, a number that ranged from slightly higher to much higher than those of the friendly forces. Later I learned the enemy numbers were mostly propaganda to make us feel better about the home team winning the war. At the time it did its magic, assuring us that our victory was inevitable, if always postponed.

The choking desert of Iraq couldn't be more different from the sweltering jungle, but the monotony of the daily score and the young faces on the TV screen are the same, idealistic and patriotic young men and women who will never grow older in the service of a misguided policy designed to increase domestic security and protect oil profits. The geography lessons have come again, as we learn place names that were unpronounceable a year ago. Even the parade of policy options attempted and discarded by an increasingly panicky White House with an eye to November elections is sadly familiar.

There is another, more hopeful, difference with this war. My mother, nowadays fixing low cholesterol dinners for one, frets in our weekly phone calls about the simple patriotism proffered by venal and greedy men who never had to count the cost themselves. Donald Rumsfeld, beware: our students may be blind to the implications of this war, but our parents are no longer fooled.

The BPD Update will begin a Back Page section starting with this issue. Please consider submitting a one-page story about your work with students, clients, colleagues, or the public. Contact the Editor for details.

Click here to send an email message to Ralph Holcomb

Next Page: President's Report

Spiral, Horizontal Line Spinning

BPD Update Online, Volume 26, No. 1, Winter 2004

The BPD Update Online Web Site is sponsored by Lyceum Books.